Final Year Dissertations or Projects - What To Consider

This guidance will help you with your preparation and the sort of content to include.

Check with your tutor before you start whether you must write an extended essay or a report.

NB Use this guidance together with the following:

There are Activities in the following guidance. If you wish to complete them and copy what you have done to the Scratch Pad, open the Scratch Pad first by clicking on its symbol on the top tool bar. Click anywhere outside the Scratch Pad and it will be minimised on the bottom tool bar (even though you cannot see the Scratch Pad it is still open). If you then click on the copy button in an Activity box your work will be copied to the Scratch Pad while it is minimised. You can click on the Scratch Pad on the bottom tool bar to check that your work is there. The Help in the Scratch Pad tells you how to use it (eg to save your work).

You can make also your own notes and cut and paste on-screen text into the Scratch Pad. You will need a floppy disk.

You can either scroll down to see all the guidance, or go straight to a section by clicking on the following:

This format
Your aims
Structure
Methods
Your contents
Style
Presentation
Editing
Improving what you do

This format

A dissertation.

A dissertation is an extended essay. Depending on your course, an essay may be 2,000 - 3,000 words long and a dissertation 6,000 -10,000 words long. It is often (not always) based on literature and theory.

A final year project.

For a final year project, the work produced is in the format of a report. A project usually (not always) involves your own research from primary sources or experiments. It also draws on literature and theory.

Common elements.

This guidance focuses on common elements for dissertations and final year projects.

The work you must do for either is very similar eg gathering information; presenting an argument.

Both allow you to explore a topic in depth, pulling together the knowledge and skills gained on your course. You work largely independently, deciding yourself what you will cover, how, and when.

Specific requirements.

Check these out before you start.

This is very important - your dissertation or project may have a significant effect on your grade.

Your course will have specific requirements for your dissertation or project. How detailed they are varies between courses. Some are very exact.

For some courses, the first part of the assessed work submitted is a proposal (or 'learning contract') - outlining your plans. This guidance could help you produce your proposal.

Courses usually give the assessment critiera against which they will judge your work.

There will be course regulations concerning the dissertation or project (eg what proportion of your final grade it counts for; what evidence you need if you are ill/have serious problems affecting your work).

It helps to look at examples of dissertations/projects from your subject (ask your tutor).

Your aims

Activity 1

Your topic.

This is often a starting point.

Open the Scratch Pad before clicking on the copy icon in this Activity (see above).

You can often choose your topic (on some courses you are given one; if you are in employment your employer may direct you to a topic).

If you can choose your topic, how will you do so? You could get ideas from: tutors; your studies; work experience (eg placement); an employer.

What topic are you thinking of?

Add to ScratchPad1

Consider the following about that topic.

Could your topic be useful to you in future (eg if seeking jobs or courses)?
How easy or difficult will it be to find information on it?
Do you have enough knowledge and skills to get started on it?
Are you interested in it (it is hard to work alone if you are not)?
Is the topic big enough for a dissertation/final project?
Is it too big for a dissertation/final project?
Could you look at it in depth in the time allowed?
Could you put limits/boundaries on it (eg look at one aspect)?

Add to function list1

You can use this box to type any thoughts about the above questions in relation to your topic.

Add to ScratchPad2

Activity 2

Your research aims and questions.

What is your aim? Do you have a hypothesis to test?

Add to ScratchPad3

What are the main questions you need to answer about your topic/aim/ hypothesis (3 or 4 help you focus, many more may cause confusion)?

Add to ScratchPad4

These are known as your research questions. You may find it helpful to identify sub-questions for each main research question. You may need to amend your main questions once or twice. If you repeatedly amend them it may be hard to stay on target.

Refer all the time to your aim/hypothesis/research questions to keep you focussed.

Structure

Structure.

For guidance on structure go to 'Essay Writing' for a dissertation or 'Report Writing' for a project (you will see a topic on possible structures for reports) in this 'Writing Skills' theme.

In both these topics look first at the the Starter Level guidance which gives the main structures. There is further guidance at Development Level.

Methods

Planning ahead.

For such a major piece of work, you need to spend time at the start identifying the methods you will use, resources/training/support needed, and how long the various tasks will take.

This section helps you think about this.

Activity 3

Your supervisor.

Can you choose your dissertation/project supervisor? If so, which tutor:

  • knows about your topic
  • can advise on your methodology (tutors use/prefer different methods)
  • would you work well with (you may need a tutor who can challenge you)
  • would best help you motivate yourself?

Who do you think could be your supervisor?

Add to ScratchPad5

There may or may not be standard ways of putting you in contact with possible supervisors. Look at 'Negotiating and Assertiveness' in 'Working with Others' in the menu to the left of the screen, for help in agreeing matters with others.

Working with your supervisor.

How could you help your supervisor help you?

Information given by your course may clarify the supervisor's role and answer the following, but you could discuss with her/him:

  • how much time can s/he give you
  • what will be the best use of that time
  • when you should meet (eg how often)
  • if you can arrange meetings in advance.

What would you do (or who could you go to) if there are difficulties between you? Look at 'Negotiating and Assertiveness' in 'Working with Others' in the menu to the left of the screen, for help in agreeing matters with others.

Activity 4

Working alone.

Working independently means self-motivation. Which of these suggestions might work for you?

Work to a time plan.
Set small tasks (completing them can make you feel good).
Choose a topic you find motivating.
You and friends encourage each other.
Ask your tutor to help you set targets.
Give yourself rewards at certain stages.
If it seems daunting, remind yourself you've written essays and reports before.

Add to function list2

What else helps you keep to a task, and what could you do to set it up?

Add to ScratchPad6

Collecting information - literature search.

 

You can copy text into the Scratch Pad on the top tool bar. The Help in the Scratch Pad tells you how. It takes up to 500 words - then you need to save your work.

What published information do you need to answer your research questions?

  • library/learning centre staff can help you see how to do a literature search
  • look at other dissertations to see how many published works they refer to
  • look at 'Information Skills' in the menu to the left of the screen
  • look at 'IT Skills' in the menu to the left of the screen for help on using computers to retrieve (find) information.
Collecting information - methodology.

If you need to collect information from primary sources your dissertation/report will need a section describing your methodology.

  • How will you collect information eg surveys, interviews, experiments? Why choose these methods?
  • Are you recording what you are doing, are your records well-organised?
  • Could somebody else check that your data are authentic, that your methods are thorough, accurate?
  • Are there ethical issues (eg confidentiality)?

Libraries/learning centres have resources on different types of methdologies (do key word searches in an online catalogue).

Look at 'Information Skills' in the menu to the left of the screen.

Planning and managing time.

 

Look at 'Action Planning' and 'Organising Yourself and Your Time', both in 'Improving Learning' in the menu to the left of the screen.

 

Which of these suggestions might work for you?

  • Break the work into manageable tasks; make a plan indicating tasks, the order to do them, deadlines; review it often.
  • Estimate how long each task will take, add on half again. It may take as long to do the writing as gathering information.
  • Identify when you work best (eg some each day or in blocks of time)
  • Look before you start at 'Essay Writing' or 'Report Writing', in this 'Writing Skills' theme, so you know what is needed.

Leaving work until the last minute causes stress which stops you thinking clearly. Resources may not be available. It may reduce your grade.

Your contents

Analysis, criticism and evaluation.

Work at this level must have analysis, criticism and evaluation. For guidance go to 'Critical Analysis' in 'Information Skills' in the menu to the left of the screen.

Synthesis.

This means pulling together all the elements of your information into a coherent whole, to make sense of it. Again, this is very important at this level. It might include:

  • summarising it
  • producing a model for it
  • creating a theory for it
  • placing it within a theory
  • identfying critical elements.

It might form a part of any discussion of your findings or of your conclusions.

Creating an argument.

Meaning here: to develop a line of thought or give reasons for a view or position.

For guidance look at the 'Your contents' sections in 'Essay Writing - What to Consider' at both Starter and Development Levels in this 'Writing Skills' theme.

If you are writing a report this guidance will also help you. The process of creating an argument is similar regardless of the format you write in.

Using information.

For guidance look at the topic 'Gathering and Using Information for Final Year Disssertations or Projects' in 'Information Skills' in the menu to the left of the screen.

Activity 5

Using evidence.

Evidence should prove your claims and criticisms.

Your statements and criticisms must be supported by evidence - either from published work or from information gathered yourself.

Have you avoided generalisations not backed by evidence?
Can you give the source of your evidence (information)?
Could you or somebody else find it again?
Is it up to date?
Is it accurate?

Add to function list3

Plagiarism. See 'Plagiarism' in this 'Writing Skills' theme. It is very important that you understand it, to avoid accusations of 'cheating'.

Activity 6

Which of the following do you most need to to give attention to?

Analysis, criticism and evaluation.
Synthesis.
Creating an argument.
Using information.
Using evidence.
Plagiarism.

Add to function list4

Style

Style.

See the 'Style' sections of the following topics for help:

Use of English - What to Consider (Development Level);
Essay Writing - What to Consider (Development Level - also look at Starter);
Report Writing - What to Consider (Development Level - also look at Starter).

Activity 7

An appropriate style.

This is a major piece of academic work and the style needs to reflect this. Some of the words which spring to mind to describe such a style include: serious; considered; measured; deep; objective; weighty; clear.

It may help to look at past examples to see what is expected in your subject area.

Look at the guidance recommended in the above box, at examples or at advice given by tutors - and consider the following (you can type beneath each question in the box).

Add to ScratchPad7

Presentation

Academic conventions

You must follow any instructions given (eg in a course handbook) about length and how the work should be presented.

You must reference all the published work you have used using the accepted conventions. Click on 'Referencing' in this 'Writing Skills' theme.

Click on 'Academic Abbreviations' in this 'Writing Skills' theme.

Layout.

Look at the topics in this 'Writing Skills' theme on 'Essay Writing' and 'Report Writing' for guidance.

Use the 'IT Skills' theme for help with word-processing and layout and style and at that theme and at 'Working with Numbers' to help with presenting tables, graphs, charts, statistics etc. Both are in the menu to the left of the screen.

Editing

Drafting.

For this, you will need to produce several drafts.

You may find writing the work hard and that it helps to do it in stages eg to write a section on methodology when you have completed any research.

At the end your task will then be to put them all together and make clear connections between them.

Editing.

Allow enough time for this.

Aim to complete your writing a week or two before the hand-in date - to allow you to proof read, edit, amend, add in last minute details.

Writing up on the last day may mean your work has inaccuracies and small errors which could reduce your mark, and which are unneccessary.

For editing checklists look at:

'Use of English - What to Consider' (Development Level);
'Essay Writing - What to Consider' (Development Level - also look at Starter);
'Report Writing - What to Consider' (Development Level - also look at Starter).

Improving what you do

Activity 8

You can type beneath each question in the box.

Add to ScratchPad8

You may find 'Action Planning' in 'Improving Learning' in the menu to the left of the screen helpful.

Written by Sue Drew, Learning and Teaching Institute, Sheffield Hallam University
Courseware designed by Mark Briggs, Centre for Multimedia in Education, Sheffield Hallam University

ŠLTI, Sheffield Hallam University 2000